The Wheels That Keep Me Rolling

When you buy a bicycle, it typically comes with wheels. Unless you’re buying a super-expensive racing bike, or a custom build where you spec out all the gear, the wheels you get with the bike are OEM wheels. They’re typically pretty average wheels, even for relatively pricey bikes. Even if you’re something of a duffer like me, wheels can make a big difference in ride quality.

If I were to draw an analogy to PC tech, buying a good set of wheels for your bike is like upgrading a hard drive to an SSD in an older PC. Adding an SSD to an older PC suddenly makes it seem like a whole new animal. The same holds true for bike wheels.

I discovered this almost by accident, back when I rode a Felt Z5. Although the Felt rode like a dream compared to my old aluminum Giant, the wheels seemed a little clunky. So when I dinged one rim, I decided to replace both wheels with a set of Shimano Ultegra WH-6700 wheels. These particular wheels cost about $400, but made a noticeable difference in how the Z5 rode and handled. The bike just seemed quicker.

Dura Ace 9000 Wheel

Dura Ace 9000 carbon fiber wheel. Note the metal braking surface.

Several years passed, and I found myself riding a 2014 Trek Domane 5.2. The 5.2 weighs around 18 pounds with its standard Bontrager Race alloy wheels. These wheels retail for about $500 a pair, but probably cost Trek much less (Trek owns Bontrager, after all). The ride was decidedly “meh” as well. I wanted a more forgiving ride, as my back had been feeling pretty fragile, so plunked down about $1,100 for a pair of Shimano Dura Ace 9000 carbon clincher wheels. These wheels have since dropped in price — you can now find them for well under $1,000.

The C24s composite construction means they’re mostly carbon fiber, but include alloy brake surfaces. While adding a little weight, metal braking surfaces tend to be more effective than purely carbon fiber wheels, particularly in wet weather. Shimano builds the hubs using bog-standard cup-and-cone bearings, rather than being sealed, which means you’ll need to have to grease them periodically, or have your bike shop do it for you. These wheels aren’t particularly sexy to look at; at a 21mm external width, they’re not really aero wheels. The hubs look pretty skinny and unassuming.

Dura Ace 9000, Full View

Dura Ace 9000, Full View

They sure do ride pretty, though.

The combination of lightweight carbon fiber frame and carbon fiber wheels yields a ride where my back hurts much less after long rides. The wheels and frame soak up much of the road vibration, and the decoupled seat post, a feature of many Trek road bikes, contributes to the smoothness of it all. The bike also seems to handle more precisely, but that could just be my imagination.

I have another Trek Domane, a 4.3 Disc I use for winter rides. Despite being supposedly softer, I found the ride of the 4.3 noticeably rougher than the Domane 5.2. Of course, the 4.3 cost less, which meant it came with a pretty basic disc wheelset. I replaced that with a set of Bontrager Affinity Pro TLR wheels, built with DT Swiss hubs. These wheels set me back about $800, but the difference in overall ride quality and handling seemed larger than the wheel swap on my daily road bike. The ride still isn’t as forgiving as the Domane 5.2, but these wheels just love to roll.

Bontrager Affinity Pro TLR

Bontrager Affinity Pro TLR

Of course, tires make a difference, too. During Northern California winters, I use Continental Grand Prix 4Season tires on both bikes — 25mm on the 5.2 and 28mm on the 4.3 Disc. The Domane 5.2 gets a tire swap in spring, to Continental 4000s, which yields better handling.

So if you have a bike you love, but the ride isn’t quite what you want, consider a wheel swap. It’s almost like getting a whole new bike, but usually will cost less.



Skip to comment form

    • Mark Schneider on April 1, 2016 at 8:43 pm
    • Reply

    If you really want to transform your ride try some Compass Tires, built on tubular casing. Wider=faster and more comfortable especially on questionable roads. Use to ride Conti’s and there’s no comparison.

  1. …AND, those wheels are funky looking as well… 🙂

    1. Everyone says that about wheels for disc brakes when they first see them. The missing brake surface do make them look a little different compared to tradition rims.

    • Ryan French on April 1, 2016 at 3:10 am
    • Reply

    Nice post and nice setup on the bike. I swear by 4-seasons and run them in 28c on my gravel bike and commuter/bike path bike as well.

    I used to race Cat 2 and I’ve found that even many non-racers are so obsessed with weight that they miss out on ride quality and handling that the right hoops with proper tires can bring.

    Your choice of the Affinity set over the Shimano C24 is a good example.

    1. Actually, I didn’t choose the Affinty Pros over the C24s. The C24s are on my primary bike I ride most days, while the Affinity’s are on my winter / rain bike.

      That also illustrates the evolving nature of road disc tech. At the time I bought the 4.3 disc, the options for wheels were pretty limited; carbon disc wheels were a big jump in price at the time. The Affinity Pros have been a good compromise.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.